Just how extreme do readers want the stories here?

[JackKovan]

As Reaper, I'm known for domination and a gorefest, but my belief is that ALL kinds of styles are WELCOME on this forum!
I think that the only requirement is that MUSCLE and its implications have to be present (otherwise, what the hell are you doing here?)

[kjm00]

That's actually the clearest guidance yet -- that if it's not about muscle at its core, it's not the right story for this board.

Something to think about -- thank you.

[Jeremy Lightning]

Hi Jack/Reaper, good to see you on here, are you still writing anything?

As for my opinion on the subject, it is up to the writer, whatever you feel most comfortable writing, go for it. As long as it has elements of muscle and strength in it, then I believe it is appropriate to post here.

[wowser1016]

I can guarantee that if you write it I will read it. Since I pretty much like everything I have read on this site odds are I will like yours as well and if you mention muscle more than once I will probably even love it. Go for it!

[Nick563]

I for one like to go pretty far, but still in the realm of reality. Big muscles on both men and women. Big cock for the males and big tits for the girls. But I also enjoy some really extreme stuff from time to time. Depends on the mood.

[fbbsmmh]

Part of the problem with this site is you have some people deluding themselves that what they write here is art. It isn't. It's porn basically. I read stuff on here and write stuff on here, to get sexually aroused. That's it. If you want to write real fiction or read real fiction then do that instead of coming on here getting uppity at what people choose to write to get their rocks off.

Like most guys here, I am sexually aroused by female muscle and strength. Unfortunately in the real world, there is a ceiling to that. Here there isn't. You can make your women 7'10 500 pounds mounds of muscle who are a billion times stronger than superman. You can make them invulnerable to bullets. You can make them cruel, you can make them violent. You can make them evil sadists  who snap Santa Claus in half to make their disobedient sons cry . I got called a psychopath for writing that, but newsflash, Santa isn't real. You can also make them essentially good but with such a rigid sense of good and evil that anyone they see as crossing that line, will be killed violently and without mercy like in my Rise of The Muscled Avenger story. Or you can make them super powerful both physically and economically, but down to earth and with a good heart, like in my Becky Anderson story.

The problem with me when I try to write stuff on here with too much plot, it just becomes too much effort to keep it going. To do so, would mean taking up time I could spend doing real writing. (To be fair I usually don't end up doing that anyway.)So that is why you see so many half finished stories on here from me. I made my Becky Anderson story to layered and complex with flashbacks etc, so realistically I will never probably finish that one. I want to eventually finish 'Rise of the Muscled Avenger', but again it becomes a pain in the ass after a while. So you might see in future, a lot of stories from me with characters I may or may not use again, but where the stories are short and self contained.

For me personally, I don't want to read long, pointless descriptions, where, if you are lucky, you might get to a small bit of muscle growth by the second or third installment. Life's too short for that in my opinion. so in my stories, the women tend to be super strong and hyper muscular at the beginning. I am open to FMG but even then the muscle growth would be at the start so we could get on with the cool stuff.

That's just me and if you want slow subtle muscle growth, that's cool too. I just won't be reading it, because I don't enjoy it. However, I also won't be going on to your story ,like a self important d1ck and criticising it for not being to my taste. Life's too short for that and it really annoys me when people do that as if they are John Steinbeck. I repeat again, this stuff is not art, it is not real writing. I am not saying people on here are not capable of doing real writing as well, just don't mix the two up.

I write these stories for my own enjoyment and arousal (if I am not hard by the second or third paragraph, I am doing it wrong) and hopefully for the arousal and enjoyment of others. If you like them tell me, if you don't like them, well, don't read them. I am not writing these for publication and I am not looking to 'improve' them. They are what they are.

There is a broad church of stuff here. All tastes in female  muscle erotica are catered for. I personally believe the only limit should be paedophilia. Even incest, while it freaks me out a bit and I don't personally approve, could potentially make for an interesting plot or sub plot. Like you are a heterosexual male with a muscle fetish. how would you cope with your mother or sister being that hot and muscular, it is a valid theme to explore, it doesn't necessarily need to be an endorsement of it.

[fbbsmmh]

Was thinking of reviving a long dormant story, but most of the fiction here is pretty extreme -- giant genitals, car-crushing cleavage, etc.  And there's nothing wrong with that, but I was thinking of smaller/gentler women.  Would that be OK as well, or should I wait until I have a story with truly massive women?

Actually, that is just YOUR interpretation. You don't want to read that  necessarily, so you see most of the stuff here as being like that. I would say point me to the stories you claim are like this, because other than what I write that and maybe 2 or 3 others, I don't really see any of that stuff on here. To be fair I think the truth is probably somewhere in between. Because you want to see more subtle stuff, you see the extreme stuff everywhere, I want to see the extreme stuff, so I see mostly the stuff with small growth. Confirmation bias is everywhere on a site like this.

[Strongwood]

Everything is on the table and everyone has different tastes so there is no right or wrong answer. Write what you enjoy writing or what you would want to read.

I prefer realistic+. I'm not typically into stories of a 500lb muscle woman. My favorites are when someone has a very descriptive story with a woman that is 120% of realistic.

[BHIM-1965]

love BRFan, Mrs Lockwood and mother-son fantasies. Strong big mom and sissy son. Mom totally and lovingly dominating her son

[nebulasparks]

Part of the problem with this site is you have some people deluding themselves that what they write here is art. It isn't. It's porn basically. I read stuff on here and write stuff on here, to get sexually aroused. That's it. If you want to write real fiction or read real fiction then do that instead of coming on here getting uppity at what people choose to write to get their rocks off.

Like most guys here, I am sexually aroused by female muscle and strength. Unfortunately in the real world, there is a ceiling to that. Here there isn't. You can make your women 7'10 500 pounds mounds of muscle who are a billion times stronger than superman. You can make them invulnerable to bullets. You can make them cruel, you can make them violent. You can make them evil sadists  who snap Santa Claus in half to make their disobedient sons cry . I got called a psychopath for writing that, but newsflash, Santa isn't real. You can also make them essentially good but with such a rigid sense of good and evil that anyone they see as crossing that line, will be killed violently and without mercy like in my Rise of The Muscled Avenger story. Or you can make them super powerful both physically and economically, but down to earth and with a good heart, like in my Becky Anderson story.

The problem with me when I try to write stuff on here with too much plot, it just becomes too much effort to keep it going. To do so, would mean taking up time I could spend doing real writing. (To be fair I usually don't end up doing that anyway.)So that is why you see so many half finished stories on here from me. I made my Becky Anderson story to layered and complex with flashbacks etc, so realistically I will never probably finish that one. I want to eventually finish 'Rise of the Muscled Avenger', but again it becomes a pain in the ass after a while. So you might see in future, a lot of stories from me with characters I may or may not use again, but where the stories are short and self contained.

For me personally, I don't want to read long, pointless descriptions, where, if you are lucky, you might get to a small bit of muscle growth by the second or third installment. Life's too short for that in my opinion. so in my stories, the women tend to be super strong and hyper muscular at the beginning. I am open to FMG but even then the muscle growth would be at the start so we could get on with the cool stuff.

That's just me and if you want slow subtle muscle growth, that's cool too. I just won't be reading it, because I don't enjoy it. However, I also won't be going on to your story ,like a self important d1ck and criticising it for not being to my taste. Life's too short for that and it really annoys me when people do that as if they are John Steinbeck. I repeat again, this stuff is not art, it is not real writing. I am not saying people on here are not capable of doing real writing as well, just don't mix the two up.

I write these stories for my own enjoyment and arousal (if I am not hard by the second or third paragraph, I am doing it wrong) and hopefully for the arousal and enjoyment of others. If you like them tell me, if you don't like them, well, don't read them. I am not writing these for publication and I am not looking to 'improve' them. They are what they are.

There is a broad church of stuff here. All tastes in female  muscle erotica are catered for. I personally believe the only limit should be paedophilia. Even incest, while it freaks me out a bit and I don't personally approve, could potentially make for an interesting plot or sub plot. Like you are a heterosexual male with a muscle fetish. how would you cope with your mother or sister being that hot and muscular, it is a valid theme to explore, it doesn't necessarily need to be an endorsement of it.

Is it strange that I conceived this comment in Norman Bates' voice? Anyone?

The bait was there and I grabbed hold of it. Couldn't resist. Hahaha.

No but for real, I never knew John Steinbeck was like that. As an author myself (I've published about 4 books; I'm gonna say that because I'm John Steinbeck), I agree that this stuff differs from modern literature, obviously. Things like paedophilia in writing are difficult to pinpoint, especially on this site. Some stuff is just too extreme here. I've reported one story that was beyond grotesque and it got removed immediately, and if someone is  upset about that, you need psychological help, I'm afraid. Writers need to stop uploading stories with underage characters being sexualized; this isn't the '70s. ITS JUST TOO FAR!

[TheMoleUK]

Part of the problem with this site is you have some people deluding themselves that what they write here is art. It isn't. It's porn basically.

But porn IS art. Just as much as thrillers or love stories. They contain as much, or as little, "real fiction" as the writer is prepared, or able, to give it.

I'm sure we've all seen non-porn pieces with far less "real-fiction" than some porn pieces.

There is no sliding scale to "real fiction" by genre. Just by individual taste & by individual authors.

Here there isn't. You can make your women 7'10 500 pounds mounds of muscle who are a billion times stronger than superman. You can make them invulnerable to bullets.

I wish they would. That is, the forum caters for the "mounds of muscle" very well. Which is fine. Whatever floats your boat as they say.

But some more of the "who are a billion times stronger than superman" and "invulnerable to bullets" would be nice. That's much more my thing & I seem to be in a very small minority on that point.

Santa isn't real.

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!! :-)

[Butt kisser]

Write whatever you feel inspired to.. like other posters have stated, there's a wide range of audience in this forum.

Since we're kinda chiming in on what we like.. I don't really like the idea of a strong woman torturing weaker men.. but I like the  storylines where the women are in complete control, and have their every whim & urge indulged by submissive men. Basically like your average American marriage 

[Jaguar]

Some authors here write porn and will always write quick porn.  And people here read it.

Others are more than that, with plots and character development.  And people here read that. 


It is the authors choice what they aspire to and what they have time for.


If an author has the time and inclination to create it, I prefer stories here with plots and character development.  But that takes a lot of time and skill to create.  I also appreciate stories that are just quick erotica.