Eh, how about... my preferred muscle would change with the ebb and flow of the girl's flex??
I find the entire body of a muscular girl more powerful than a drug. If you want to talk strictly preferences, and force me at gun-point to PICK ONE, and ONLY ONEEE!! Um, I'd still be fighting with indecision, between abs, a girl's armpits, glutes, quads, or overal core. Last second, before you pull the trigger, I'd shout from the innerest crevices of my soul..... "ABS, NOO THE ASS!! NOOO MAKE THAT THE ABS/CORE!! ACK, SHOOT ME, THIS IS TORTURREEE!!!! Gwhaa" I'd be rendered into a crybaby, toughest choice ever.
FYI, heck, the saddness that breasts are fat and that ultrafit women will shed breasts, is one of the things that pains me. Because my ideal fantasy is supremely muscular women with equally gigantic bosom mounted over steel-plated pecs. My brain has this elaborate city palace where muscle women live in a strict hierarchy. The more muscular/busty essentially queens, and those that can't compete like hiding in maze like alleys for fear of being crushed by the superior ladies in the hierarchy...
So, this type of questions, man, they really are tough, because makes me trigger that inner brain catalogue of images that I have....